| Platinum | Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers |
| Gold | Flock Wine Bistro |
| Silver | Nick and Stella's Family Sports Pub |
| Bronze | 3 City Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Bayside Grill |
| Top Pick | Capone's Coal Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Downtown House of Pizza |
| Top Pick | McGregor Pizza & Deli Company Line |
| Top Pick | Pizza Pub |
| Top Pick | Uncle Riccos |
| Redbone's Bar & Grill |